The Truth About Divorce Mediation v. Litigation
Mythical Expectations of Divorce Court
Having spent years in the divorce litigation trenches (in our former lives as divorce attorneys), we've heard the following many times:
Of course, for many high conflict couples, it's natural to imagine a
"shock and awe" style of court victory in a divorce or parenting trial - one
that is hugely satisfying. Even less conflicted parties often assume that a
divorce trial means "being heard" and achieving
complete and satisfactory Orders from the judge.
- "I can almost always get a better result, if I go to court and tell the details of my story there," and
- "I've been told that divorce mediation almost always results in less optimal divorce settlements, than litigation."
Most experienced divorce lawyers and other divorce court observers know,
however, that it
is asking too much of a judge not acquainted with your family's unique
circumstances - to discern all truth from fiction and to dispense perfect
justice after a hearing constrained by limits of time as well as court
formalities and rules. As divorce attorney-mediator, Diane Neumann, has written:
The reality of a divorce court trial is that most litigants walk out of the
courtroom feeling as if they have just been run over by a truck. Even the winner
often finds his or her enthusiasm dampened by the warning they hear from their
divorce lawyer: to prepare for the next legal round, when their ex-spouse
appeals the judge's decision.
For most divorcing or separating
parties, then, their feelings after trial are not those of elation, but of disappointment at best, and
emotional and financial devastation at worst. In every instance of a delighted divorce court victor, of course,
there is the other spouse who feels hugely defeated or even humiliated. The
difficulty in such a polarized case is in predicting "which end of the stick"
you will find yourself.
In many, if not most, litigated cases, the truth is that neither
spouse feels they achieved any "victory." And, for couples with
children, any short-term "spoils" of the battle may be considerably less valuable than
the long term benefits of
preserving a working relationship with the other parent. Morevover, even when both parties
do find courtroom results reasonable, legal fees and emotional costs exact their toll on parties and their families - sometimes a crippling one.
Conclusion: Your Divorce, Your Choice
To be sure, there are cases and issues where negotiation or compromise may be
short‑sighted, and litigation with its opportunity to be heard is a risk
worth taking. No divorce process (litigation, mediation, arbitration) is
appropriate for all divorcing parties or cases.
Generally, however, divorce
mediation is the sensible, affordable option that results in both parties having
greater control, a more satisfying divorce experience and often, an optimal
result for their family's moving forward in a positive fashion after separation and divorce.
So, what, then, is the the truth about divorce mediation v. litigation?
It is an important question, with no "one-size-fits-all" answer. For most couples,
however, we believe mediation easily bests the
scorch and burn, "War and the Roses",
winner-take-all, lawyer fought, custody battle litigated approach to divorce!
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Christopher L. Griffith, J.D., M.S., and Lawrence F. King, J.D. are full-time Colorado divorce and family law
attorney-mediators with Divorce Resolutions®, Colorado Center for Divorce
MediationTM. For more information, visit their award-winning website, with its
mediation: frequently asked questions & myths and other family mediation
resources, Colorado divorce law information with free
planning tools and Colorado divorce forms, and "Best of the Net" parenting plan resources. (www.ColoradoDivorceMediation.com)
Chris or Larry can be contacted by phone at (303) 650-1750, or E-mail
| || |
Follow Us On
THIS WEB SITE IS PROVIDED FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY
Do not take any actions based upon the information contained within this web site without first consulting an attorney or an appropriate professional depending upon the content of the information.